Main

 
Sample Reviews

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sample Reviews

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

KLIATT publishes reviews of paperback books, hardcover young adult fiction, audiobooks, and educational software recommended for libraries and classrooms serving young adults.  The following code is used to help readers determine if the material reviewed is appropriate for their needs:

J -- Recommended for junior high & middle school students
S -- Recommended for senior high students
A -- Recommended for advanced students and adults.
*  -- The asterisk highlights exceptional material.

SAMPLE REVIEWS FROM KLIATT'S LATEST ISSUE:

 

HARDCOVER YOUNG ADULT FICTION

 

Myers, Walter Dean. Sunrise over Fallujah. Scholastic. 304p. map. c2008. 978-0-439-91624-0. $17.99. JSA*

Twenty years ago, Myers wrote Fallen Angels, a classic YA novel about a 17-year-old African American soldier’s experiences in Vietnam. In this companion novel, that man’s nephew, Robin, writes to his uncle about his experiences serving in Iraq in 2003, and once again Myers (who served in the army himself, and whose son is a career officer who served in the first Gulf War) succeeds in communicating the horrors of war from a YA’s perspective. Robin is part of an advance Civil Affairs Unit whose mission is to help Iraq’s noncombatants, “making friends with anyone they don’t kill.” But in this complex conflict, it’s hard to figure out who the good guys and the bad guys are, and winning hearts and minds isn’t easy when you’re busy ducking IEDs (Improvised Explosive Devices: a glossary is appended). In the episodic tale, Robin is befriended by blues-playing Jonesy and feisty Marla, endures a two-day sandstorm, and participates in a secret mission to negotiate for kidnapped children, among other adventures. All the while, he tries not to show his fear as he experiences all the noise, smell, confusion and terror of war.

Myers succeeds in making the reader feel what it’s like to be in Iraq, though Robin remains something of a blank slate. His friendship with Marla helps shine light on what it’s like to be a woman serving in today’s army. This somber novel will help anyone trying to understand the war and the experiences of our military there. Paula Rohrlick, KLIATT

 

 

SCIENCE FICTION

 

Popescu, Petru. Birth of the pack. (Weregirls.) Tor. 347p. c2007. 978-0-7653-1641-7. $9.95. JS

Lilly Willson thinks her school needs a girls’ soccer team, so she and her three friends start a club team, called the Weregirls after a Native American story her dead father used to tell. Little do they know that Lilly’s father was a supernatural Guardian, and the team is about to get pulled into a supernatural battle: there’s a new girl in town, and she wants magic powers more than anything. Andra will stop at nothing to steal the power of the Weregirls, and only by tapping into their own supernatural natures will the Weregirls survive. This first book in the series is a rollicking good adventure, with sports, boys, cliques and the power of love and friendship. Recommended for all collections. Deirdre Root, Ref. Libn, Middletown PL, Middletown, OH

 

 

GRAPHIC NOVELS

 

 

Tamaki, Mariko. Skim. Art by Jullian Tamaki. Groundwood. 208p. illus. c2008. 978-0888997531. $18.95. (hardcover.) S*

Kim Cameron (Skim to everyone) wants to be a witch, but hasn’t quite gotten the hang of it. She breaks her arm tripping over her altar; the Wicca ceremony in the park turns out to be an AA meeting; and when she and her best friend Lisa try to channel the spirit of Michael Reddear, the boy who killed himself, nothing happens. When Lisa asks what they would do if he appeared, Skim says—“nothing, I guess. Ignore him.” Skim goes to a private high school for girls; ever since Michael Reddear died her classmates are obsessed with suicide. Skim’s self card is the Lovers, reversed. She is in love with her teacher, Ms. Archer, who should know better.

Skim is about being in a certain place in your life—friends come and go, falling in and out of love; being 16, and liking it. The narrative is first person, with diary entries, and manages to avoid the usual clichés; the characters don’t line up to tell us their life stories. The b/w art is fluid and curvy and looks like it came straight out of a sketchbook. The little details are wonderful—the sun face on Ms. Archer’s door; the Girls Celebrate Life bulletin board; Lisa tugging at Skim’s jacket. Skim contains vulgarity (s and f-bombs), witches in training and tobacco use by minors. Highly recommended for high school graphic novel collections, especially those catering to girls. George Galuschak, YA Libn, Montvale PL, Montvale, NJ

 

 

HISTORY

 

Richards, Leonard L. The California Gold Rush and the coming of the Civil War. Random House, Vintage. 289p. illus. notes. index. c2007. 978-0-307-27757-2. $14.95. A

California’s history has always seemed more sprightly than that of other states, and anything connected with the 1849 Gold Rush makes it seem especially so. Popular histories of the gold-fueled emigration are plentiful, but this book takes a slightly different angle. Before the first nuggets were pulled from the millrace at Sutter’s Mill, California was a remote and thinly populated backwater only two years removed from Mexico’s sleepy jurisdiction. The demographic landslide that shortly took place, however, transformed California not only into a rip-roaring frontier territory, but a political prize of great significance in the brewing dispute over slavery. The 1840s were, of course, a time of wide-open and uninhibited political expression throughout the new republic anyway. In California, the situation was exacerbated.

Author Leonard Richards, a professor of history with roots in the Golden State, enjoyed himself in putting together this story of crude politics and often cruder men, clever maneuvering and outright chicanery, all spiced with a heady mixture of gold miners, entrepreneurs, outlaws and vigilantes. Fully annotated and with a fine index, Richards’s book is academically respectable, yet his delight in the subject will convince AP students and adult readers that history can be enjoyable in its own right. Raymond Puffer, Ph.D, Historian (retired), Edwards AFB, Lancaster, CA

 

 

AUDIOBOOKS—FICTION

 

Danticat, Edwidge. Krik? Krak! Read by Robin Miles & Dion Graham. 5 tapes. 5 hrs. Recorded Books. 1991-1995/2007. 978-1-4193-9563-5. $33.75. Vinyl; content notes. A

This marvelous collection of short stories records the violence and brutality of life under the dictatorship of the Duvalier family in Haiti. The stories represent many perspectives on women’s lives in this culture and reflect the continuing struggle to preserve family and self-respect in this oppressed country. “Krik?” is the call of the storyteller and “Krak!” is the response of the enthusiastic listener. In this way, Haitians pass on a rich oral tradition from generation to generation. These tales are somber in tone, full of sadness, struggle, and suffering. Stories introduce the listener to the tragic separation of lovers when one, a rebel, must flee the island by boat for his life; a daughter who watches her elderly mother abused in prison; a woman who earns her living as a prostitute while her son sleeps; an infertile woman who picks up a dead baby and cares for it; and a Haitian immigrant mother who must adapt to life in New York City, including her daughter’s marriage to a non-Haitian.

Stating in her Epilogue that her writings are “a testament to the way these women lived and died,” Danticat, a Haitian American herself, brings them to life again as part of the living chain of women through history. Miles and Graham share the narration, sometimes alternating voices in a single story, more frequently alternating stories. Miles, an acting and accent coach as well as an assistant professor of speech, renders realistic, deeply emotional portrayals of her female characters. Graham, an experienced actor and veteran audiobook reader, brings the sometimes pathetic, often ill-fated characters to life by utilizing a wide variety of accents and inflection in these eye-opening stories. Susan Allison, Libn, Lewiston HS, Lewiston, ME

 

 

AUDIOBOOKS—NONFICTION

 

Cathcart, Thomas & Daniel Klein. Plato and a platypus walk into a bar; understanding philosophy through jokes. Read by Johnny Heller. 4 cds. 4.25 hrs. Recorded Books. 2007. 978-1-4281-7379-8. $51.75. Vinyl; content notes. SA

What a refined, intelligent, hilarious hoot! Move over, Woody Allen. The authors see philosophy and comedy as flip sides of a coin. From Aristotle to Augustine, Nietzsche, Descartes, and Sartre, many philosophical schools are revisited through jokes. Most of the jokes are hilarious: e.g., a Buddhist walks up to a hot dog stand and says, “I’ll take one with everything,” pays, and asks for his change. The vendor says, “Change comes from within.” Even the ones that aren’t so funny make you think. This doesn’t soft pedal philosophy—your eyes will still cross as you attempt to grasp the explanations; but, at least you’re offered the gift of laughter as the authors skillfully move from expurgation to another great joke.

Heller’s narration is lively, with a somewhat tongue-in-cheek pomposity that fits the framework of the production. Covering a huge territory, this is a great Cliff Notes comedy that reviews the main points of the major philosophical traditions. Nancy Crowder-Chaplin, Libn, VCCW, Goochland, VA